Hariri Tribunal: Prosecutor Publishes Indictment Against Four Hezbollah Members

Hariri Tribunal Indictment Hezbollah

ELIZABETH A. KENNEDY and MIKE CORDER   08/17/11 02:25 PM ET   AP

BEIRUT — A long-awaited international indictment unsealed Wednesday offers no direct evidence linking four Hezbollah suspects to the 2005 assassination of Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, despite years of painstaking investigations.

The indictment, which relies heavily on circumstantial evidence such as telephone records to link the men to the crime, played into efforts by the powerful Iranian-backed Hezbollah to discredit a case that has consumed and divided Lebanon for more than six years.

"The text in our hands now based on analysis and not clear evidence," Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah said in a speech. "Those who were indicted should not be called charged but unjustly treated."

Much of the information contained in the indictment had been leaked to the media over the past two years, which Nasrallah said was a sign that the probe was tainted beyond repair.

Lebanon's most powerful political and military force, Hezbollah has vowed never to turn over the suspects, although a trial may be held in absentia.

"The full story will, however, only unfold in the courtroom, where an open, public, fair and transparent trial will render a final verdict," said Daniel Bellemare, the prosecutor at the U.N.-backed Special Tribunal for Lebanon.

The suicide truck bomb that killed Hariri on Feb. 14, 2005, was one of the most dramatic political assassinations in the Middle East. A billionaire businessman, Hariri was Lebanon's most prominent politician after the 15-year civil war ended in 1990.

In the six years since his death, the investigation has sharpened some of Lebanon's most intractable issues: the role of Hezbollah, which commands an arsenal far greater than the national army, and the country's dark history of sectarian divisions and violence.

Hariri was one of Lebanon's most powerful Sunni leaders; Hezbollah is a Shiite group.

Prosecutors analyzed a vast network of telephone records to link the "assassination team" to the suicide truck bombing that killed Hariri and 22 others, according to the 47-page indictment. Investigators tracked the movements of the suspects using their phones' locations as recorded by cell phone towers.

The indictment says the records showed "a coordinated use of these phones to carry out the assassination." According to the records, there was a flurry of calls shortly before Hariri's murder, but they stopped two minutes before the explosion.

The phones were never used again.

The indictment also says the assassins tracked Hariri's movements over several weeks to establish the routes and movements of his convoy and the location of his vehicle in it. On the day of the murder, they detonated some 2,500 kilograms (5,510 pounds) of explosives packed into a Mitsubishi van parked near a hotel along Beirut's Mediterranean waterfront.

Prosecutors acknowledge in the indictment's preamble that they have no direct evidence linking the suspects to the attack. The file relies to a large extent on circumstantial evidence "which works logically by inference and deduction," the indictment said.

Media reports last year suggested that the Hariri case would hinge on telephone records, and Nasrallah has worked to cast doubt on the security of the system.

Lebanese officials have confirmed that Israel has penetrated Lebanon's telecommunications networks and has great control over them. In 2010, authorities detained two senior employees of one of the country's two cellular telecommunication companies on suspicion of spying for Israel.

The telecommunications minister at the time confirmed that Israel was able to infiltrate Lebanon's mobile telecommunications network and could manipulate phone calls and short messages.

Nasrallah has said Israel bugged the mobile phones of Hezbollah members, allowing it to make false phone calls, send false text messages and track the users' movements.

The indictment alleges the plot's mastermind is Mustafa Badreddine, a Hezbollah commander and the suspected bomb maker who blew up the U.S. Marine barracks in Beirut in 1983, killing 241 Americans.

The other suspects are Salim Ayyash, also known as Abu Salim; Assad Sabra; and Hassan Oneissi, who changed his name to Hassan Issa.

Prosecutors alleged Ayyash led the assassination team and the two other suspects were responsible for a false claim of responsibility intended to throw investigators off track.

Hariri's son, opposition leader Saad Hariri, urged Nasrallah to cooperate with the tribunal.

"What is required of Hezbollah's leadership is simply to announce their disengagement with the accused. This stance will go down in history," he said in a statement released by his office.

Hezbollah has always had serious muscle, but the group has amassed unprecedented political clout in the government, having toppled the previous administration in January when Saad Hariri – who was prime minister at the time – refused to renounce the tribunal investigating his father's death.

The new premier, Najib Mikati, was Hezbollah's pick for the post.

____

Corder reported from Leidschendam, Netherlands.

FOLLOW aol WORLD

BEIRUT — A long-awaited international indictment unsealed Wednesday offers no direct evidence linking four Hezbollah suspects to the 2005 assassination of Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, d...
BEIRUT — A long-awaited international indictment unsealed Wednesday offers no direct evidence linking four Hezbollah suspects to the 2005 assassination of Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, d...
Filed by Eline Gordts  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 69
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:02 PM on 08/18/2011
Also this international tribunals are nest of incompetents. If you want a good lough just watch ICT procedures against serbian politician Sheshely (Šešelj) who is a trained lawyer (i just loved when he and prosecution withess proved that prosecution was operating with forged documents). Look of suprised cow in prosecutors eyes was priceless
12:54 PM on 08/18/2011
Interestingly one always forgets the eternal question "Que bono" who benefits. Well from all i read the hariri assasination was neither in Hezbollah or Syrian interest. Only one who did benefit from it was their neighbour to the south. If you recapitulate in aftermath of the assasinantion Syria did pull from Lebanon at great US and Israeli rejoicing. Untill their pullout all the worlds media and US/Isareli official souces were shouting "Syrians did it" without any proof as they are now shouting for last few years "Hezbollah did it". Hezbollah is much more modern (technologically and in their thinking) that west is ready to addmit. Their communication network was a nasty suprise for Israelis in 2006 i.e. fiberoptic cable C4I network (Command, Control, Communications, Computers, and Intelligence) all trough the south Lebanon which consequently had no "good targets" (mostly identified by radio intercepts Hezbollah readily admits heavy losses where they relied on radio) and stated to bomb civilians. Their fiberoptic network was also one of the main disputed that brought the hariri jr. goverment down (the other being the attempt to post pro Isareli chief of Beirut airport) On the other note it is a rather great pride of Hezbollah leadership that education and especcialy education of women is getting higher.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yonatan c
01:40 PM on 08/18/2011
what world do you live on? Hariri was against Syrian influence in Lebanon. Hezbollah was and still is a staunch backer of Syria. How can you say they didn't benefit? sure it backfired on them, but they couldn't have known this was going to happen. As for Israel how did they benefit?
01:45 PM on 08/18/2011
Hariri was impotent against both Syria and Hezbollah and as such only a gnat in their ear. Israel benefited by Syria moving 10.000+ soldiers and inteligence/counterinteligence poeple out of Lebanon.
photo
YafoDalet
a secular Jew
09:42 AM on 08/19/2011
Right. Hezbollah had no benefit from Hariri's assassination. And pigs fly.
10:45 AM on 08/19/2011
But the do (i mean fly - they just need a good runway):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7laPLF5w3Ys
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
powercomptroller
10:29 AM on 08/18/2011
HP scared to post my comments regarding the Israeli drone that just happened to capture the explosion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
donklinestiver
Country doctor for 48 yrs
10:21 AM on 08/18/2011
Sheik Hassan Nasrallah will protect his fellow killers of women children and the inocent. Hiding behind his religious Haloween costume and claiming God made me do it. Our hope remains the youth of the Middle East see the futility of these old bearded men and their phoney retoric.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
powercomptroller
10:17 AM on 08/18/2011
Ah but there is. Hezbollah released footage of the bomb attack that they intercepted from AN ISRAELI DRONE. I guess the drone just happened to be flying in the neighborhood to say hello to some other drone friends. The western media has been all over it....NOT.
photo
Marcus047
given up on HP
11:47 AM on 08/18/2011
are you sure it wasn't a spy-vulture?
01:07 PM on 08/18/2011
Acctually Hezbollah is quite good at intercepting Israeli drone footage. They did announce that they even broke the encryption of signal which is normaly used in more expansive drones (strategic recce). From what they said their analyts did not gave particualr significance to the footage (and previous Israeli survailance footage of Hariri sr.) as they had a backlog and they were concentrated on Israeli survailance of the south Lebanon. Their characterised it as "our bad analysis".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yonatan c
01:40 PM on 08/18/2011
they were good at it in the 90s (when it actually happened) nothing in 2005 though. if so please prove.
07:35 AM on 08/18/2011
Kangaroo trial
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jon Jony
12:55 AM on 08/18/2011
Only about 35 posts on here....

Of course - because its not about Israel. Pathetic
07:44 AM on 08/18/2011
Oh it is about |$rae|.... more than you think
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jon Jony
08:21 AM on 08/18/2011
I am very much aware that conspiracy theorists like yourself are obsessed with Israel because it is associated with Jews.

Anti-semitism is a sickness; a plague on the earth and unfortnately you have the disease. It is unfortunate because it makes you an angry hateful person.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yasunari
Video meliora, proboque, deteriora sequor
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rurichman
11:02 PM on 08/17/2011
And this is the kind of government that the world wants? This corruption, this terrorism, is what Hamas and Fatah are exactly alike. And with out Israel their actions would also go without punishment and justice. They are no different than Hezbollah and Israel know's it, see's it think's it and feel's it. A two state solution with whom. Look at the peace treaty with Egypt, in todays paper in Egypt they are accusing Israeli hairdressers of putting chemicals into Egyptian hair products to cause infertility in Egyptian women. How much is that treaty worth, how much longer will it last. When will Arabs and now Persia initiate another war against Israel?
10:35 PM on 08/17/2011
What a joke; in the criminal justice system, phone records do not constitute probable cause for an indictment. The upshot to all this is that there is no hard, physical evidence tying these individuals to the murder of Hariri. The Special Tribunal for Lebanon is a miserable, failed attempt by an USRAELI star chamber to sew internal division in Lebanon. It won't work. The Israeli bombs and white phosphorus which fell on Lebanese civilians and infrastructure in 2006, along with the numerous invasions and violations of sovereignty, speak more eloquently than trumped up circumstantial "evidence". The fact of the matter is that Israeli pride was severely wounded at their vaunted IDF-enjoying superiority in armour, air support, naval support and artillery- being worsted at the hands of a handful of light infrantrymen in the South of Lebanon. Humiliation smarts, big time.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rurichman
11:06 PM on 08/17/2011
your a blind racist that will deny anything no matter how obvious if it shows the any fault toward Hezbollah, Hamas, Fatah and probably Iran as well. But this point is useless to you isn't it, your blind...right....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce banned
Never let them tell you it can't be done.
10:09 AM on 08/18/2011
Oh, it is the sort of circumstancial evidence that not only was accepted in the US criminal justice system, but convicted a number of Black and poor defendants, who DNA evidence later cleared.

(oh, and people like rurichman spent years proclaiming that the people who said that there was a problem with the bias that ran through the police and justice systems were 'conspiracy theorists', 'bleeding hearts', 'soft on crime' etc. These convictions usually involved no active conspiracy, or even overt racists being involved, just the small, unconcious bias of one person building on the small, unconcious bias of another, each step amplifying until the result is almost monstorous)
photo
climbing panda
there's a log in my cabin
07:57 PM on 08/17/2011
i have to wonder if nasrallah truly and fully believes what he says, that it is an israeli plot, or if he lives with the knowledge that he is deceiving his faithful? akin to the cardinals and bishops of the catholic church who deceived their followers about pedophilia.
photo
tallen
panem et circenses
07:49 PM on 08/17/2011
My guess is that they are all dead.
Nasrallah wouldn't want the possibility to exist that they could be caught and talk.

Because they didn't do this on their own. Nassrallah had to give the order, and he takes his orders from Syria and Iran.

Dead men tell no tales.
Bernique
Solar is clean, cheap and plentiful
07:30 PM on 08/17/2011
In European accounts of this event, Hezbollah is responding that they are being "set up", and point the finger at us, the U.S. Just sayin'
photo
SaneUSA
American, Jew, Zionist.
07:33 PM on 08/17/2011
Shocking.
photo
Marcus047
given up on HP
11:50 AM on 08/18/2011
a terrorist organization is blaming someone else for killing the elected and well liked president of a country they are trying to take over? What are the chances.
Bernique
Solar is clean, cheap and plentiful
06:53 PM on 08/19/2011
Marcus -- then it must be that other little country in the region that is trying to destabilize Lebanon, you know the one that builds walls and gets its monies and weapons from this country? Hezbollah is [socialist] political party, it was democratically elected.

The reason we are in Iraq, Libya, and go after Iran is that they also have popular [socialist] democratically-elected parties.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce banned
Never let them tell you it can't be done.
07:18 PM on 08/17/2011
For anyone who is interested in getting behind AP's spin, here is the document

http://www.stl-tsl.org/x/file/TheRegistry/Library/CaseFiles/PreTrialChamber/20110816_F0012_PUBLIC_PRV_PTJ_Confirmation_Decision_Filed_FR-EN.pdf
photo
Wozzeck
Pearl Bay, Australia
07:07 PM on 08/17/2011
Relying on cell phone records?

"Then telecommunications minister Charbel Nahhas confirmed at a news conference held with experts in the field in November that Israel was able to infiltrate Lebanon's mobile telecommunications network and could manipulate phone calls and short messages"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:30 AM on 08/18/2011
Happened to me once.
I wanted to date this cute Ukrainian girl and then I get the phone message from "her" that she would not go out with me EVER cause I'm 2" shorter then her and not exactly a Brad Pitt, and overall nerd. I was shocked. It's only like 1 and 3/4 of an inch...
Now I know it's all Israelis fault, they wanted me to date within the tribe.

Well, if they were capable of manipulating phone calls back then...
photo
Wozzeck
Pearl Bay, Australia
11:08 AM on 08/18/2011
Keep working on your schtick. With a little luck you will be knocking the seniors dead at Yakov Smirnoff's in Branson in no time.
photo
wom122
Primum non nocere
06:51 PM on 08/17/2011
No surprise. The tribunal has been an abysmal failure right from the start. I know not what purpose is served by indicting Hizaballah except either to re-ignite a sectarian civil war or justify the salaries of those who pass for prosecutors.