Vatican Publishes Internal Abuse Files For Ronan Case

Vatican Abuse Files

NICOLE WINFIELD   08/17/11 02:28 PM ET   AP

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican, reeling from unprecedented criticism over its handling of sexual abuse cases in Ireland, took a pre-emptive strike Wednesday and published some internal files about a priest accused of molesting youngsters in Ireland and the U.S.

The files published on the website of Vatican Radio represent a small, selective part of the documentation the Holy See must turn over to U.S. lawyers representing a man who says he was abused by the late Rev. Andrew Ronan. The man, known in court papers as John V. Doe, is seeking to hold the Vatican liable for the abuse.

A federal judge in Portland, Oregon, ordered the Vatican to respond to certain requests for information from Doe's lawyers by Friday, the first time the Holy See has been forced to turn over documentation in a sex abuse case.

The partial documentation released Wednesday includes the 1966 case file with Ronan's request to be laicized, or removed from the clerical state, after his superiors learned of accusations that he had molested minors in Ireland.

The Vatican said the files, a few dozen pages, some handwritten and culled from its internal books, represented the full, known documentation held in the Vatican specifically about Ronan. It said they prove that the Vatican only learned of Ronan's crimes in 1966 when his order sent Ronan's personnel files to Rome and asked the pope to remove him from the priesthood, a year after the abuse against Doe occurred.

More documentation is expected to be handed over to Doe's lawyers by Friday since the judge's discovery order also requires the Vatican to provide information about its general policies handling sex abuse cases and how it trains, educates, selects and removes priests. Much of it is expected to be in Latin.

The Vatican's decision to publish the Ronan discovery documentation online marked an unusual attempt at some transparency, particularly given the sensitivity surrounding internal personnel files of accused priests. Victims groups have long denounced the secrecy with which the Vatican handles abuse cases and demanded the files of known abusers be released.

But it comes amid unprecedented criticism of the Vatican's handling of sex abuse cases in Ireland, and as it still seeks to recover from the fallout over the abuse scandal that erupted last year. Thousands of people in Europe and elsewhere reported they were raped and molested by priests as children while bishops covered up the crimes and the Vatican turned a blind eye.

Last month, an independent report into the Irish diocese of Cloyne accused the Vatican of sabotaging efforts by Irish Catholic bishops to report clerical sex abuse cases to police. The accusations prompted Irish lawmakers to make an unprecedented denunciation of the Holy See's influence in the predominantly Catholic country, with heated words in particular from Prime Minister Enda Kenny.

In a statement accompanying the document release Wednesday, Vatican attorney Jeffrey Lena said the Vatican's documentation should help "calm down those people who are too quick to make sensational and unfair comments without taking the time to get an adequate understanding of the facts" – an apparent reference to Kenny's denunciation.

The Vatican recalled its ambassador to Ireland over the ruckus to help prepare an official response, which is expected in the coming weeks.

According to the Holy See, the documentation released Wednesday includes the 1966 case file held by the Vatican's office for members of religious orders, known at the time as the Sacred Congregation for Religious, containing documents in English, Italian and Latin related to Ronan's request to be laicized.

The file contains a 1963 letter written by the Chicago-based provincial of the Order of Servants of Mary to the order's headquarters in Rome detailing accusations that Ronan had abused students while he was a teacher at the Servites' Our Lady of Benburb Priory in Ireland.

The provincial wrote that he had "removed" Ronan immediately from Ireland after discovering the abuse accusations in 1959. Ronan began working in Chicago and was later transferred to Portland. He died in 1992.

While the letter does not mention Vatican involvement in the transfer, it clearly implicates the Servites in placing a known child molester in a Chicago high school, St. Philip's. The provincial, whose name is illegible, wrote that after transferring Ronan from Ireland to Chicago, "I am expecting the worst any day here at St. Philip's but much better that it occur here than in a seminary."

Lena said in a statement that the files show that the Holy See didn't learn of the accusations against Ronan until 1966, after the abuse against Doe occurred in Portland and after the laicization request was sent to Rome. "The Holy See was not involved in Ronan's transfers, including the transfer to Portland, and had no prior knowledge that Ronan posed a danger to minors," he said.

He said the Vatican was releasing "all known documents relating to Ronan held by the Roman Curia" to help the Oregon court determine the remaining jurisdictional question in the case: whether Ronan was an employee of the Holy See, which is critical to determining whether the Vatican can be held liable for the abuse Doe endured.

None of the documents released Wednesday relate directly to that core employment question. Rather, they seek to support the Vatican's contention that it had no prior knowledge of Ronan's crimes before 1966, that it wasn't responsible for transferring him and therefore isn't liable for the abuse Doe suffered.

The Vatican says religious orders, and not the Vatican, are entirely responsible for transferring their priests around the world, just as individual dioceses are responsible for transferring diocesan priests from place to place.

Lena said Doe's attorney, Jeffrey Anderson, never had any evidence to support his "calumnious accusations" that the Vatican itself had transferred Ronan to Portland while knowing that he posed a danger to minors.

Doe's lawyers, Lena said, "have nonetheless chosen to misuse the legal system as a vehicle to pursue a broader agenda – a decision that has misled the public and wasted considerable resources."

Anderson said Wednesday that at first blush, the documentation raised more questions than it answered.

"It's a very suspicious, limited and selective release and is far from what has been required and ordered by the court, and raises more concerns about candor and the completeness" required of the Vatican, Anderson said by telephone.

Anderson has filed hundreds of lawsuits against priests and dioceses in the U.S. concerning priestly sex abuse. In addition to the Portland case he has named the Holy See as a defendant in two other U.S. lawsuits, in Milwaukee and Chicago.

The main U.S. victims' group, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, welcomed the Vatican's release though it noted that it did so only because it was forced to by a court and had resisted such discovery requests for nine years.

"It's clear that this is a desperate, last minute Vatican ploy to seem ever-so-slightly less recalcitrant than it has been for decades with clergy sex crimes and cover ups," said Barbara Dorris, SNAP's outreach director.

___

Online:

Vatican documentation is http://www.radiovaticana.va/pdf/documents_Doe_v_Holy_See.pdf

FOLLOW aol RELIGION

VATICAN CITY -- The Vatican, reeling from unprecedented criticism over its handling of sexual abuse cases in Ireland, took a pre-emptive strike Wednesday and published some internal files about a prie...
VATICAN CITY -- The Vatican, reeling from unprecedented criticism over its handling of sexual abuse cases in Ireland, took a pre-emptive strike Wednesday and published some internal files about a prie...
Filed by Bryan Maygers  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 185
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
08:32 PM on 08/21/2011
The Vatican is marking World Youth Day celebrations in Madrid by offering women who have had abortions an easy way to become Catholics again, reports the Guardian. Abortion is punishable by instant excommunication and "normally, only certain priests have the power to lift such an excommunication, but the local diocese has decided to give all the priests taking confession at the event this power," explains a spokesman for Pope Benedict XVI.

Some 200 confession booths have been set up. A private one for Frakerin, in central Madrid for the 6-day event, which is expected to attract well over a million pilgrims as well as plenty of protesters. The Spanish government will be covering some of the costs of the $72 million event, which will include a visit from the pontiff tomorrow. Even some members of the clergy are questioning the wisdom of holding such a lavish celebration when Spain is in the midst of an austerity drive, and youth unemployment has reached 40%,
$72 MILLION! Rick Scott got elected for $73 Million
05:31 AM on 08/19/2011
What a joke! The Pope should be arrested, the moment he sets foot on land not owned by the Vatican't. And, by the way.....in case you're not aware... it's International Youth week for the church.... I guess they're out there looking for fresh asses to Rape! and Minds to wharp! Why are churches not being burnt to the ground, people, and priest-offenders not being hung by their balls??? If you continue to allow the church to get away with it by turning a blind eye, then the abuse will never stop............. you SHEEPLE!!!!
12:15 PM on 08/19/2011
I firmly agree, this a travisty of the C-assolic church. I'm sorry I may have confused you with another in the comment section
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RadicalAmerica
Common sense for the common man
04:46 AM on 08/19/2011
Want to do some good and love your fellow man?
Don't try to be a Catholic or a Buddhist, or a Jew.

Try just being a humanist.

Think for yourself and take care of the people around you.
You'll find that goes a lot further than any mythical idol can take you.
05:33 AM on 08/19/2011
Amen, amen, amen............
12:19 PM on 08/19/2011
Your message is exactly what I'm trying to get through to people. Thier god is inside them .. or not. Peace be with you.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HomeGrower
Independent - so both sides hate me
03:14 AM on 08/19/2011
As a Catholic I wish the church would just end this by admitting its mistakes and fully cooperate with law enforcement. There is no defending their actions. With that said, I still believe the vast majority of the church does great things for its members and non-members.
05:34 AM on 08/19/2011
Take the blinders off and look around........... Your church is the greatest curse ever purpetrated on the human race.
08:38 AM on 08/19/2011
totally agree mr koch. i grew up in the catholic church and the hipocracy make's me sick! it turned me off of any organized religion for the rest of my life. "do as i say, not as i do". i suppose the gate's of hell yawn before me because of this post. your's truly, "a lost sheep".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HomeGrower
Independent - so both sides hate me
07:47 PM on 08/20/2011
Our church provides many benefits, including chances for me to get to know my kids friends and their parents. I think that is so important today. They have a great Little League program and pancake breakfests, where the dads cook for the kids. We also get donations from local biz and we provide the labor to fix problems for the elderly and handicapped like holes in roofs and walls, or build a ramp, etc.

Like I said, the church has its problems but is anything out there perfect?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rini1946
02:06 AM on 08/19/2011
on the whole I think that the people in the catholic church are good people. And at one time the priest and nuns were decent people. With a few of them being in the I am holy than thou. It happens in most professions. Look at cops about 5% of them are hey I got on a uniform I am a god .What I am saying is you can't judge a whole group by the actions of a few. There are ministers out there are nothing more than snake oil salesmen. I get tired of hearing if you plant your thousand dollar seed it will grow into 10 thousand dollars. Look at the bakers She would cry on tv everyweek about the poor people out there that needed thier support and she had a closet full of over 1000 shoes and she said after they were caught people know when i go shopping i spend a 1000 dollars. I am not sure if they start this way or become this way.
StevenRussell1
Christian Pilot
01:56 AM on 08/19/2011
"He who believes in the Son has everlasting life; and he who does not believe the Son shall not see life." -John 3:36
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nottenkamper
10:13 PM on 08/18/2011
I agree with my friend walking wolf, on the number that are still hidden, is a mystery for us and only THe Church to know. They would probably have few priests left, if all were known. As we know they are hurting for priests now, and few are answering the call. Maybe time for the laity
to take over? Like all organizations, there is little clarity about who is doing what...even our own
government. We expect religion to be pure, and that is a farce. Even Jesus, had his Judas.Probably best to be a monk, or hermit out alone, in continous prayer away from all others.
On the other hand, Mother Theresa of Calcutta did no harm. I think FEW are called, and the
rest are hiding out, and doing evil, which will be on tab at their death. I would hate to be the
Pope and have all this evil on my hands, which if he hides, is liable.
We are really all on our own to think, and decide what our Spritual life will be, and how we will
answer to a moral life.
photo
Just Don
"Just", like "merely"
09:57 PM on 08/18/2011
Reminds me of the joke: I prayed for a bike but was told god doesn't work that way. So I stole a bike then prayed for forgiveness.

And that's how god works.
05:00 PM on 08/18/2011
This is nothing! Until the Catholic Church ejects every last pedophile hiding behind the vows of a priest, it will be considered a mockery among religious groups. Perhaps it is time they come into the 21st century and do away with the ridiculous rule that priests and nuns must be celibate. Peter was a married man before becoming a priest.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gcymru5491
04:43 PM on 08/18/2011
Biggest concern for the Catholic church? Self preservation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HomeGrower
Independent - so both sides hate me
03:05 AM on 08/19/2011
Doesnt every entity and person have the same goal?
05:37 AM on 08/19/2011
Sure, but the church does it as a detriment to humanity!!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
freedomfighter30
Say NO to Socialism - Been there, lived that.
05:49 AM on 08/19/2011
Throughout the ages the Catholic Church has had doozies of popes. About 68 of them. But ya know what? Their faith has continued through all the scandals. So it's not who is "on the throne of Peter" it's their continuing belief in their faith and the churches' teachings which has sustained them through this mess. It's not only the Catholic church that has problems. No one church or place of worship is exempt from human failings.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RadicalAmerica
Common sense for the common man
04:42 PM on 08/18/2011
In the history of the world, nothing has been the catalyst of more grief, hatred, war, and crime than religion. Religion allows a person to hate, kill, torture, or steal, while allowing him to recuse himself of all blame. Religion causes people to break the laws of ethics and morality in the name of a god.

Religion dulls the mind and weakens the senses. It makes "God did it" seem like a reasonable answer to anything at all, squelching questions of why, how, and when, and replacing these questions with repeated mantras and prayers to nobody.

Religion is exquisitely profitable, with most adherents tithing a portion of their income. The churches, synagogues, and mosques, which do little to serve their community outside of "outreach programs" (marketing and recruiting), pay almost no taxes.

Religion spreads like disease through societies, rarely coexisting with pre-existing mythologies, rather preferring to conquer or be conquered. Religion is anything but tolerant.
photo
alterego55
Flash your citations or leave!
05:56 PM on 08/18/2011
Its a tribal mentality. If you're not part of the tribe, then you're the enemy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RadicalAmerica
Common sense for the common man
08:11 PM on 08/18/2011
Good analogy.
05:39 AM on 08/19/2011
Well then, I'm proud to be on the 'Outside'
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dav0001
I can't believe you people
12:58 AM on 08/19/2011
Aren't you being just a little bit harsh there?? Religion is a wonderful thing that brings light to millions of people. How I was able to type all that without laughing so badly I got a stroke is beyond me. Agree with everything you said.
photo
Joe Mando
Oh say...Can you see?
04:13 AM on 08/19/2011
That "light" causes religious fanatics to walk around with a glassy-eyes look in their eyes that reminds me of a deer in the highway at night.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RadicalAmerica
Common sense for the common man
04:34 AM on 08/19/2011
Why is the human brain so great in common sense when it comes to anything other than religion? Try to sell me the Brooklyn Bridge, I see ya coming a mile away. Tell me about a grandfatherly figure that lives in the clouds and I look up and try to see him.

PATHETIC and SAD.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RadicalAmerica
Common sense for the common man
04:36 PM on 08/18/2011
And the conspiracy continues.

What does this say about your catholic spiritual leaders now? The deceit of the flock goes right to the top and falls squarely on the shoulders of the pope himself. How can you BLINDLY follow a group whose very leader is suspect? How can you consciously tithe to a group who kicks up 23% to these leaders to pay for criminal case attorneys?

When will you start to think for yourself and save the little children?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HomeGrower
Independent - so both sides hate me
03:09 AM on 08/19/2011
"How can you BLINDLY follow a group whose very leader is suspect?"

You just described members of both our political parties. Only independents truely think for themselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RadicalAmerica
Common sense for the common man
04:23 AM on 08/19/2011
One registered Independent here reporting for duty.
05:45 AM on 08/19/2011
Why do you think they call their members SHEEPLE? They're easily lead to the slaughter.
04:06 PM on 08/18/2011
Please don't paint the whole Church black because of the actions of a few. What these priests have done is not right, and it is horrible that it is being denied, covered up, and ignored. Beacause of these priests standing in the church, we held them to a higher standard, and we were let down. By men we trusted, men we trusted our children with. But, I don't hold the entire Catholic church responsible. I can't. Do u hold an entire race responsible for the actions of one? Or a group?
photo
alterego55
Flash your citations or leave!
04:46 PM on 08/18/2011
When even one Bishop or Cardinal is prosecuted and jailed for playing "Where's Waldo" with pedophile priests, or for obfuscating evidence, then I might agree with you. Start with Cardinal Mahoney.

Until then, I condemn the entire church because it is a systemic protection racket.
04:56 PM on 08/18/2011
Don't condemn us all. Do you condemn Mother Teresa? You can go into any of her convents or institutions around the world, and they are happy to show you their books. I know, I did so at her convent in Peoria, IL
05:46 AM on 08/19/2011
Keep forgiving, fool, that's what they're hoping for...........
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BinghamLofts
03:41 PM on 08/18/2011
this is all about money.
03:04 PM on 08/18/2011
Iam a Catholic brought up as a Catholic and i will always believe in GOD. But as far as the church goe's and the Pope forget it.
04:45 PM on 08/18/2011
Can say the same about Washington DC. Your absolute judgment seems strangely repetetive by people with any authority problems.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Erica McClellan
Don't Be A D...!
08:23 PM on 08/18/2011
Religion has nothing to do with faith, hon. Good choice.