logo


James Van Praagh Offered $1 Million To Prove Mental Powers

First Posted: 08/23/11 06:09 PM ET Updated: 10/24/11 06:12 AM ET

Self-proclaimed psychic James Van Praagh has certainly done well for himself through doing readings, writing books about the psychic world and helping to create the CBS drama "The Ghost Whisperer."

Still, even with all his success, you'd think he wouldn't pass up a chance to earn a quick million bucks, right?

If you predicted yes, your answer would be wrong -- at least up to now.

That's because the James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF) has issued a challenge to Van Praagh and other people who claim to have psychic ability: It will pay $1 million for anyone who can produce evidence of paranormal abilities under controlled conditions.

It's not a new deal by any means: The Foundation has made this offer since it was founded in 1996 "to expose charlatans and help people defend themselves from paranormal and pseudoscientific claims."

So far, no one has been able to collect on the money, not even a well known psychic like Van Praagh, whom the organization is singling out in order to capitalize on his particularly devastating appearance on a recent episode of "ABC’s Primetime Nightline: Beyond Belief," a one-hour special that explored whether such a thing as psychic ability exist.

During the episode, Van Praagh performed a reading on "Good Morning America" anchor Josh Elliott.

Although Elliott initially appeared surprised by Van Praagh’s accuracy, he revealed that “every talking point of the reading” seemed to have been lifted from a two-year-old interview with Elliott that was available online.

"I'd known there was plenty of information regarding my past readily available with a cursory Internet search, including an extensive interview that included all the talking points [such as] my dead relatives and my adoption," Elliot said during the show. "Except, I thought, for [my mom's boyfriend] Leo."

Elliott rechecked that interview when he got home from interviewing Van Praagh and discovered that interview had a reference to Leo's passing, "able to be exploited along with the rest."

During the show, Van Praagh denied using Google, but declined to do a reading on Elliot's segment producer, claiming he had become too tired.

In a later part of the show, Allison DuBois, who appeared on Bravo's "Real Housewives of Beverly Hills" and is also billed as the inspiration for the CBS drama "Medium," performed a similar reading on ABC News correspondent David Wright as did self-proclaimed medium Rebecca Rosen.

Both readings focused on Wright’s family and his late mother. Wright was surprised by their accuracy and said they revealed “details that don’t pop up on Google.”

Yet, shortly after the show aired, a Twitter user posted a link to a wedding announcement from The New York Times that contained the relevant details about the Wright family.

JREF founder James Randi makes no claims of intuitive ability, but his gut tells him that both Van Praagh and DuBois "should be embarrassed by the transparent performances they revealed to the world on last night’s show.”

Randi would like those two -- and other psychics -- to put their alleged powers to the test under scientific conditions and not rely on "cold reading," a technique that uses questions to get key points to focus on, for example, through prompts like, "I see a woman with an 'M' in her name...?"

Although cold reading in itself isn't bad -- as long as it is labeled as such or presented as a party trick -- Randi is disgusted by how Van Praagh and DuBois use it to "prey on families’ deepest fears and regrets,” he said.

To be fair to Van Praagh, there are some academics who claim his powers hold up under scientific scrutiny such as Dr. Gary Schwartz, a former Yale professor now at the University of Arizona.

"I've been very impressed," Schwartz said on the "Primetime Nightline" episode. "He is real and accurate and, on the average, among the best of the mediums I've seen."

Randi may be skeptical about psychic powers in general, but he figures the easiest way to prove him wrong is for real psychics to take up the challenge.

"If anyone does have psychic powers, and can prove it [the money is there]," he said. "I am surprised people aren't hammering down my door."

HuffPost Weird News reached out to Van Praagh for a comment about his performance on the ABC show and any plans to take Randi up on the $1 million challenge. So far, there has been no response -- something Randi predicted.

"All these guys -- Van Praagh, DuBois, Uri Geller -- they know we know how to set up a test," he laughed. "Whenever Uri Geller or Van Praagh are asked about the test, they change the subject."

Another guy who does "cold readings," John Edward, was once asked about the challenge and, according to Randi, he said, "I never talk about a guy whose name is also a verb."

Randi said, "The interviewer laughed and changed the subject."

WATCH:

Related Blog Posts

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 109
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
BannedInBoston
Everyone is entitled to my opinion.
09:48 PM on 08/31/2011
So-called "psychic powers" are real but they are also notoriously unreliable and difficult to consciously control, especially under controlled conditions, which have been shown to have an inhibiting effect. Unfortunately, because of this, some psychics do, on occasion, resort to "faking it" it in order to achieve better consistency of results. This mix of authenticity and fakery has given the whole field a bad name. At any rate, the Amazing Randi has no intention of ever giving that $1 million to anyone, no matter how authentic a demonstration a psychic puts on. He can always say, I could do the same thing by sleight of hand....
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
11:12 PM on 08/25/2011
There is no reason to believe that Randi's million dollar challenge is legitimate:
http://weilerpsiblog.wordpress.com/randis-million-dollar-challenge/

There is also a million dollar challenge for skeptics:
http://www.victorzammit.com/skeptics/challenge.html

Strangely, no one has claimed that prize either. It would seem that when skeptics have to actually back up their statements, you can hear the crickets chirp.

Here is what real scientific evidence looks like:
http://weilerpsiblog.wordpress.com/evidence-for-psi/
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Craig 212
Tide goes in, tide goes out.
07:23 PM on 08/26/2011
The "million dollar challenge for skeptics" is impossible; you can't prove a negative. He may as well hold a million dollar challenge asking to disprove the existence of the tooth fairy.

As for Randi's million dollar challenge: this specific challenge might not be a scientific one. It might be a huge scam. But there are plenty of actual legitimate scientists out there who are willing to test without bias, so what's the hold up?
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
08:29 PM on 08/26/2011
You're the second person that has misinterpreted this. The objective of this challenge is to demonstrate that the evidence for the afterlife, (NDE's and all that) is spurious, does not meet ordinary standards for evidence and is not fit to stand up to a scientific challenge.

It is an impossible challenge because no one can demonstrate that all of the existing evidence is no good. Zammit's money, like Randi's, is safe.

If you're looking for actual science, look at the bottom of my post above, there is a link to the scientific evidence for psi.

Truthfully, these challlenges, bot Randi's and Zammit's are just showboating. (I'm sure both of them know that.) No one is going to collect on either challenge. Bringing up the skeptic challenge is just a way of turning the tables and hopefully forcing some of the more intense skeptics to see the discussion in a different light.

Testing for psi has been ongoing for 130 years. About fifty years ago they started laboratory testing, moving away from psychics and mediums and other gifted individuals and focused on testing larger groups of ordinary people.

The data is actually very convincing. It meets any sane scientific standard, but it is largely ignored by the rest of the scientific community because it does not fit into any accepted theories.

Skeptical organizations also work hard to confuse the issue. This is CSICOP and of course, JREF. That's it in a nutshell.
12:34 PM on 08/29/2011
Nonsense. Randi's $1 Million Challenge is perfectly straightforward. Whatever the "psychic" claims to do, just do it under controlled conditions. If somebody claims they can bend spoons, or read minds, or whatever, they must do it under conditions that preclude cheating. The only reason for a "psychic" to refuse the challenge is if they know their powers are bogus.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
O K Ali
Wash your hands, seriously.
09:36 PM on 08/25/2011
My psychic test is simple. Punch em in the face, if they are there to take the shot in the kisser, fraud. If you can't find them, they just might have the ability.
11:30 AM on 08/25/2011
If you use your psychic powers for personal gain, you will lose them. It is one of the Universal Laws. It is one thing if you accept a donation but to made rich by such a huge offer or using your gift to win the lottery is wrong. This is a true fact. Perhaps James doesn't want to take the chance. Besides why does he have to prove anything? He only owes himself the truth. To feel moved to have to prove to others is just an ego thing.
12:25 AM on 08/30/2011
this is ridiculous! "if you use your powers for personal gain..." WHERE is this universal law written? "this is a true fact" WHY? because you said it? James doesn't even have to use it for personal gain, he can donate the money to a children's hospital. "Besides why does he have to prove anything?" because he's the one making the claim! It's theft by deception otherwise. he takes money for personal gain EVERY TIME he does a show! HE makes millions preying on the ignorance and gullibility of others.
photo
360Dunk
Feeder of slot machines
10:42 AM on 08/25/2011
In an unrelated story, Jessica Simpson was also offered $1 million to prove mental powers.
10:14 AM on 08/25/2011
James Van Praagh can start by locating the missing lady in Aruba, right?
10:13 AM on 08/25/2011
This guy is pure BS with capital letters, come forward and tell us who killed Jon Benet Ramsey! Do it now, and many other things we want to know....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
roadking01
democrats fighting 4 america
09:52 AM on 08/25/2011
hey guys. charlie byrd here. for some reason i can't seem to sign on through yahoo so i had to sign up at huff post with a new name. that said "i dont believe in this mumbo jumbo". i believe in god.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
roadking01
democrats fighting 4 america
12:07 PM on 08/25/2011
does anyone know how i can change my friends and fans to my hp account? if not,guess i will have to start all over.lol thanks.charlie byrd from softail96ci@yahoo.
09:42 AM on 08/25/2011
I know what's going to happen in the everyday world such as,....there will be another hurricane larger than Irene coming and will hit land in Florida and continue up inland the east coast this time causing great destruction in Washinton D.C. and another 6.9 Ouake hits Mexico city a round 2:00 pm tomorrow causing light damage, now where's my million dollars?
photo
360Dunk
Feeder of slot machines
10:40 AM on 08/25/2011
I'll get it in the mail for you....AFTER the Mexico City quake tomorrow.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
mosuro
Snake Oil
08:58 AM on 08/25/2011
how come we never hear of a psychic winning the lotto?
10:26 AM on 08/25/2011
Actually, there is a woman that has won it twice, a former school teacher that said she has a psychic method that she applies to the numbers, she won't tell what she does...that's all I know about this...
photo
baddunion
Federalist for the Republic!
08:58 AM on 08/25/2011
The President has just confirmed
> that the DC earthquake occurred on a rare
> and obscure fault-line,
> apparently known as "Bush's Fault".
>
> The President also announced that the Secret Service
> and Maxine Waters continues an investigation
> of the quake's suspicious ties to the Tea Party.
>
> Conservatives however have proven
> that it was caused by the founding fathers
> rolling over in their graves.
>
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Dougsholmes
"I don't need no stinkin' badges"
09:34 AM on 08/25/2011
Leave the comedy - if that's what you think it is - to the professionals. Keep your day job, bagger, if you have one, because every other bagger has been telling this joke for the last 24 hours.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mszags
09:52 AM on 08/25/2011
FYI....maybe you, in your "repub bagger extremism" missed the fact that this isn`t a political story or are you that desperate??????
08:40 AM on 08/25/2011
These people pray on the most vulnerable of human emotion, loss of a loved one. Who amongst us wouldn't give anything to talk with a dearly departed? Are they OK? I miss you, I love you, etc etc... I know I would if I were able to. I wish it were that easy. Pay someone, hold their hands, and talk to your departed. These "psychics" know that there are many people out there who would pay and do anything for this chance, so they play to them just like any other salesperson does. Do I think there are people out there with REAL psychic abilities? To a certain extent, yes. But do I think that its as simple as going to anyone in the Yellow Pages, paying money,and having a conversation, absolutely not. Houdini studied this more than anyone.He told his wife Bess secret codes, so that if he died, she would know it was him contacting her. And that he would do everything possible to make contact after his death. Every year until her death she tried and tried, but to no avail. Who knows? They say we only use 10% of our brains capacity. Could there be people out there who use more and thus are able to see and hear what we cannot? Way too much for my 10%, LOL.
anjade
What would Xena do?
09:42 AM on 08/25/2011
Dear ProRanger, While I agree with almost everything that you say, please don't fall for the myth that we only use a fraction of our brains. Just think about it, why would our brains evolve to the size they are only to use 10% of the total capacity? We may not know the function of certain areas of the brain, but that doesn't mean it is wasted space or that it exists as a ESP or psychic area. The brain is a complex organ, (even though some people refuse to use theirs) and I'm pretty sure we use 100% of it for something.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mszags
09:58 AM on 08/25/2011
here`s another option...maybe, just maybe there s nothing after death...but no, humans could never accept the fact that they are not immortal and that their time on this earth is all you get....could not live with that notion...would open up all kinds of issues about being responsible for our own actions and would add a whole new meaning to the saying,"you only get one shot....make it count!!"
08:37 AM on 08/25/2011
One psychic I went to said that I was about to lose some money---they he said I owed him $50.
02:15 AM on 08/29/2011
LOL..No kidding.........
08:26 AM on 08/25/2011
We need to offer this challenge to preachers and priests. They would fail as well.
10:32 AM on 08/25/2011
I doubt there would be any takers. The psychic realm is not their forte'.
07:43 AM on 08/25/2011
This little Randi man reminds me of Rumpelstilskin. He's a magician by trade; of course he's going to ask "trick" questions.
12:27 AM on 08/30/2011
he was a magician by trade almost 40 years ago...