logo


'Kismet,' Play About Muslim Poet, Pulled By School Over 9/11 Complaints

Muslim Poet Play

First Posted: 09/20/11 10:36 AM ET Updated: 11/20/11 05:12 AM ET

Associated Press

JOHNSTOWN, Pa. — A western Pennsylvania school district has decided not to stage a Tony Award-winning musical about a Muslim street poet after members of the community complained about the play on the heels of the 10th anniversary of the September 11 attacks.

The Tribune Democrat of Johnstown reports Richland School District had planned to stage "Kismet" in February but Superintendent Thomas Fleming says it was scrapped to avoid controversy.

Fleming tells the newspaper that sensitivity is understandable in part because one of the hijacked planes crashed in nearby Shanksville.

Miller says the play has no inappropriate content but he and other members of the performing arts committee decided to switch to "Oklahoma!" after hearing complaints.

"Kismet" won the Tony for best musical in 1954.

RELATED VIDEO:

Related Blog Posts

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 56
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:17 PM on 09/21/2011
All you intellectually challanged individuals carrying on about this not being a play about terrorists are missing the point. The point is that Christian and Jewish themed productions and "traditions" have been banned by most schools. Why should Islam be any different. Why should a play with islamic prophet's and deities be exempt from this? God and Jesus have been removed from schools, but as soon as Muhammad is the outcry is deafening. This has nothing to do with the play being linked to terrorists and has everything to do with being fair in the exclusion of religion from public schools. Sorry Muhammad you're not allowed in the schools either.
photo
jimtpat
Hell's Pretty Pink Bells
05:57 AM on 09/21/2011
Yessiree, you're darn tootin' they should replace "Kismet" with "Oklahoma". This is America!

So, I wonder who they'll get to play Ali Hakim?
10:40 PM on 09/20/2011
There's American terrorism for you. Give in to it, spread it; the hate and fear, round and round and round.
12:05 AM on 09/21/2011
It's not terrorism to take out the terrorists! I guess that makes you the enemy of peace.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mamabeverley
10:45 AM on 09/21/2011
But this is a play about a poet, not a terrorist. @Jampa is talking about the fear mongering the gov't has instilled into Americans so we are afraid of our own fracking shadows. That way, we don't question giving up our Constitutional Rights, or Civil Liberties. Ya know, like that pesky search and seizeure law. How about illegal wire tapping with out a warrant?? I know, "if you're not doing something wrong, you have nothing to worry about....B.S." the FBI is putting tracking devices on peoples cars for no good reason,other than the fact they are of the Muslim faith, (2nd generation AMERICANS, with no ties to a foreign gov't) with not even a hint of wrong doing. If they will do it to "them", they will do it to "us". People are so busy living in fear, they are not living. I wonder how many of the people that complained even know a Muslim!
09:19 PM on 09/20/2011
they should not do a play that involves a cult. islam is a cult.
photo
jimtpat
Hell's Pretty Pink Bells
06:13 AM on 09/21/2011
Yeah, the school district will probably gain a lot from a production of "Oklahoma" with it's themes of peer pressure to commit suicide, purchase of a mind-altering drug from a Middle Easterner, a murder fantasy, and finally an American good old-fashioned knife fight resulting in manslaughter.

The kids will love it!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mamabeverley
11:07 AM on 09/21/2011
And so was David Koresh in Waco. There are many different types of cults, many of them christian based. By the way, the main theme of Kismet is about a poet. Not a terrorist. Does that mean we can get rid of Shakespere?? He was not well liked during his time, maybe he was part of a cult too, and we just don't know it.

Btw, do you know even 1 person if Islamic faith? Like really know them and their families? To sit down and have dinner with them? I think not, otherwise, you would know they are just regular people, trying to pay the bills like the rest of us.
07:22 PM on 09/21/2011
You're right lady. You're the only person in the whole wide world who knows a muslim practitioner. Keep your ignorant presumtions to yourself.
JimOKC
Logic, not ideology...
06:55 PM on 09/20/2011
I did a text search on the play, and the Muslim prophet's name and the Muslim deity's name are mentioned many times throughout the script of the play. If you are OK with that, then you are OK with a play that mentions God and Jesus throughout the play, or Buddha, or Confucius. If you are not OK with any one of those, then you are not OK with any of them. I'm not passing judgement either way, because frankly I don't care. But, to be fair, one has to apply any rules evenly across the board or not at all. Logic, not ideology.
12:03 AM on 09/21/2011
Your ideology is based upon a biased "pluralistic" view.
05:46 PM on 09/20/2011
OH NO! "Kismet" is a beautiful musical. The thought never crossed my mind watching a production of this play about "Muslims???" Oh well, the world is going bananas, I guess? Too much stress!
JimOKC
Logic, not ideology...
06:57 PM on 09/20/2011
Search the text of the play. It mentions religious names many times. If you are OK with that, then you are OK with plays that mention other religion's deities and prophets as well throughout the play. Think about it.
08:49 PM on 09/20/2011
So what! The score is beautiful....... By the way are you writing this comment from another country or somethings??? AMERICA, FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND EXPRESSING ONE'S SELF??? That is what they taught us in school if I remember correctly!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mamabeverley
11:18 AM on 09/21/2011
I am ok with that.
05:33 PM on 09/20/2011
Christmas, Chanuuka, and other religious themed plays have been banned for years now. I see no difference in this. HA How dare we treat the Muslim religion in the same ways we've treated Christianity and Judaism for years. God Forbid. There are plenty of plays with no religious undertones that this shouldn't even be an issue. What's good for the goose is good for the gander.
06:33 PM on 09/20/2011
Uh, except it's not religiously themed. It happens to take place in Arabia, that's it.
07:35 PM on 09/20/2011
Do some research then comment next time. You're wrong.
04:50 PM on 09/20/2011
I live in the Richland school district and I think this is ridiculous. How hypocritical we are to cancel a play because the characters are Muslim. That's a real good way to teach our kids not to hate. I love Johnstown, but it is a backward town with a lot of backward, bigoted people who are stuck in the past. You know, there was a terrorist bombing in Oklahoma City too, maybe they shouldn't do that play either. And we better blacklist Joseph and the Technicolor Dream Coat too because it's set in the Middle East. Sad.
12:08 AM on 09/21/2011
We need to ban it because it is Muslim. Islam is based upon a politico-religious system which seeks to conquer by the sword. It is the enemy of peace and has always been. Therefore it should be banned as should the Muslim religion, in a fair and democratic society.
photo
Walks702
Vote or DIE, mutha-f
04:21 PM on 09/20/2011
Five months after??? Not exactly on the heels...and NO this is NOT understandable...an award winning musical has absolutely NOTHING to do with pathetic cowards who crashed planes on 9/11...Or if it does, would someone puulease explain it to me???
mm3264
Volunteer Of America, Occupy Wall St
03:45 PM on 09/20/2011
What about Americans who fear real terrorists like Republican Senator Tom Coburn who tried to deny 9/11 responders health care. They still aren't covered for all the rare cancers popping up.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimall3
02:46 PM on 09/20/2011
The US Constitution forbids Government actors - including School districts from banning plays based on the content of those plays. It is called "content restriction" and is ILLEGAL. It would be like banning the constant nonstop showings of ANN FRANK because of its secret Zionist message.

But we cannot expect a place as Provincial as Pennsylvania to follow the law can we?
05:00 PM on 09/20/2011
So that means we can put Christmas content back into Christmas at the schools, too!! I'm so glad you told me about content restriction.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pkafin
06:28 PM on 09/20/2011
jimall3 missed a word. That word would be "solely". Generally, the govt. should not restrict speech or expression solely based upon it's objection to the message.

Christmas content, which is not actually banned across the board, runs afoul of Constitutional rights unrelated to objections about the specific content. The objections that are raised regarding Christmas content center on the idea that the govt. should neither restrict nor endorse any specific religion.

To clarify by example: A school cannot state "During our December holiday celebrations, we will have an assembly and sing hymns praising Jesus but will block and songs in Hebrew or those mentioning the Islamic Prophet.

However, the school/govt can say "In December we will not devote any public resources to celebrating any religious holidays. We will not support Christmas related activities. Nor will we, so much as give appearances to, celebrate Hanukkah, Quanza, or Festivus (even though festivus appears inclusive and secular)".

Likewise, from a legal perspective, a school can choose to have a holiday assembly and present songs from a variety of religious traditions. Practically speaking, there are smart and not so smart ways of having such an assembly and avoiding potential community hassles.
05:49 PM on 09/20/2011
I challange you to show me where in the constitution this is. I don't believe the constitution restricts schools from choosing or not choosing a certain type of play for their children to perform.
01:39 PM on 09/20/2011
This country is becoming quite petty and self-righteous.
photo
Ossit
Ossit
12:36 PM on 09/20/2011
They do tallnavy. You just refuse to hear.
12:01 PM on 09/20/2011
I hope no one comes out crying about this. If any muslims come out and get offended...then they should pubically denouce radical islam and the 9/11 attacks.
12:40 PM on 09/20/2011
To tallnavy, I totally agree with your comment
12:53 PM on 09/20/2011
"Kismet" had NOTHING TO DO WITH RADICAL terrorism!! What is wrong with this country?!? It is a BEAUTIFUL uplifting musical with wonderful songs and a happy ending for cryin' out loud!!! Behavior like this only shows, again, how ignorant Americans are - and plays right into the hands of the real terrorist lunatics who attacked us, by DIVIDING us against each other ...