logo


Peanut Butter And Jelly Racist? Portland School Principal Ties Sandwich To White Privilege

Peanut Butter Jelly Sandwhich

The Huffington Post     First Posted: 09/11/12 06:53 PM ET Updated: 09/13/12 11:39 AM ET

A lunchtime staple of students for years, the peanut butter and jelly sandwich could be considered one of the more popular items found in the sack lunches of school children.

But in conjunction with recent equity training in local Portland schools, one principal is raising questions about the mention of the sandwich, arguing it has broader implications about race, the Portland Tribune reports.

The sandwich was reportedly mentioned in a lesson plan last year. Verenice Gutierrez from the Harvey Scott K-8 School used it as an example of a subtle form of racism in language, according to the report.

"What about Somali or Hispanic students, who might not eat sandwiches?" Gutierrez said, according to the Tribune. "Another way would be to say: 'Americans eat peanut butter and jelly, do you have anything like that?' Let them tell you. Maybe they eat torta. Or pita."

As part of a training program known as "Courageous Conversations" that has been phased into Portland schools in recent years, the Tribune reports that staff members at Gutierrez's school have been going through trainings, classroom observations and exercises, such as reading a news article and then talking about it from the perspective of "white privilege."

The organization behind the program is Pacific Educational Group. According to the group's website, their aim is to help minority students through initiatives that address racial educational disparities, "intentionally, explicitly, and comprehensively."

Since word of the news spread, however, several bloggers and Twitter users took issue with the claim that a sandwich might be racially charged and deemed the principal's statements absurd.

The author of a post on Twitchy.com wrote that "The sane are quick to rightly mock this latest asinine claim."

The author then featured a selection of tweets mocking the implication that mention of the sandwich has anything to do with race issues:

"[W]hat's the verdict on grilled cheese? Racist? Sexist?" one person tweeted.

"All sandwichs are racist! It's the name "sandwich" the poor tortas are discriminated against!" another wrote.

Robb Cowie, the communications director for Portland Public schools, told Fox News that the district was on board with Gutierrez's comments.

"Persistently we have not done a good enough job educating students of color and specifically African-American students," Cowie told Fox. "That's what the program is addressing. How can we find a way to support African American students, their families - so that we are producing better outcomes and narrowing the achievement gap."

Recent data from the U.S. Department of Education highlighted racial inequity in a survey of 72,000 schools. Minority students faced harsher discipline and were more likely to be taught by lower paid teachers with less experience than white students, according to a press release.

 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
orgivemedeath
02:37 AM on 10/01/2012
There is some truth to these claims. Chunky Peanut butter is an insult to weight challenged people, and of course, substituting Nut-tella is an insult to the insane. If you use Apepricot jelly, you're insulting Magilla Gorilla and the dude monkey from Planet of the Apes and if you use Boysenberry, you are anti-girl. These things are important and we all must laud this great teacher for no sane reason whatsoever.
03:52 PM on 09/17/2012
Peanut butter was invented by a black man.
06:57 AM on 09/18/2012
NO, it was not..peanuts, which are native to the New World tropics, were mashed into paste by Aztecs hundreds of years ago. Evidence of modern peanut butter comes from US patent #306727 issued to Marcellus Gilmore Edson of Montreal, Quebec in 1884, for a process of milling roasted peanuts between heated surfaces until the peanuts reached “a fluid or semi-fluid state.” As the product cooled, it set into what Edson described as “a consistency like that of butter, lard, or ointment.” In 1890, George A. Bayle Jr., owner of a food business in St. Louis, manufactured peanut butter and sold it out of barrels. J.H. Kellogg, of cereal fame, secured US patent #580787 in 1897 for his “Process of Preparing Nutmeal,” which produced a “pasty adhesive substance” that Kellogg called “nut-butter.”
05:42 PM on 09/19/2012
I see you have managed to bumble your way onto Wikipedia.  See if you can scrounge up an actual reference book, and you will find that George Washington Carver is credited with the recipe for the kind of peanut butter you find in a Jiff jar.  Accordingly, I don't think suggesting peaunut butter sandwiches should qualify as racist.   
02:26 PM on 09/17/2012
It's as if "white" people have always had it so great. All whites are not from the same lineage. There are Jews, Italians, Polish, etc not to mention the varied religions that white people subscribe to; each going through ethnic struggles all over the world. It all boils down to treat others as you want to be treated. We're all created by one God and put on this earth for a purpose. That purpose is not to harm others. Personally, people like this teacher, try to divide us
12:28 PM on 09/17/2012
When I attended John Adams High School, we studied about the Vanport flood, the limited opportunities for persons of color, and efforts to remove blacks from Portland after World War II. Seems like things have gone downhill since the 70s. That would be a disgrace!
10:54 AM on 09/17/2012
How intelligent! A PB&J is normalized, is common American food and she makes the solid point that immigrated kids or kids of all backgrounds have different comfort food. I think the issue isn't so much that a PB&J represents privilege but that for some teachers, different means worse. Which explains why kids with darker skin are penalized more harshly. Bravo to the school district for paying attention and changing! :)
09:53 AM on 09/17/2012
I can see where she is coming from....however that just has a lot to do with language. Those are not only latin/mexican foods, they're also the spanish language....we wouldn't call them voileipä either but that isn't anything against Finnish people
08:29 PM on 09/15/2012
What about peanut butter and jelly tortillas? Seriously, that lady is so desperate to find racism she has to pick on a sandwich?