logo


Dana Bagby, Virginia Woman, Owes $15,000 Utility Bill, City Says Pay Up (VIDEO)

First Posted: 12/06/12 EST Updated: 12/07/12 EST

Outraged Richmond, Va., resident Dana Bagby said she doesn't understand how she could possibly owe the city more than $15,000 in unpaid utility bills, but according to the Department of Public Utilities, that's what she owes, and that's how much she'll have to pay.

According to WTVR, an error on the city's part meant Bagby was never notified that the city was charging her for payments she said she paid, and they say they never received.

Department of Public Utilities spokeswoman Angela Fountain said "this fell through the cracks. It certainly did."

Bagby is vowing to fight the monster bill, and told WTVR, "Somebody needs to do something. Somebody needs to help me."

Bagby is not the first person to be shocked by an enormous utility bill, however.

Kristin Harriger in Abilene, Texas, was sent a bill for nearly $1.4 million this summer, including a $66,000 late fee. She quickly learned that her bill was an error, and that her utility company was charging her $1,000 per kilowatt hour rather than the normal rate of 8 cents to 12 cents an hour.

Similarly, in August, a Connecticut woman discovered that for 25 years she had been paying for the electricity used to power streetlights near her home. Grace Edwards was eventually reimbursed for the $10,500.

And in November, a Maryland man fought a $19,000 power bill sent by his provider, Pepco, eventually contacting a consumer protection agency and sharing his story with local news stations. Ira Ludwick's strategy worked, and eventually Pepco relented, and the billing issue was resolved.

 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:08 PM on 12/08/2012
Even before seeing the photo, I knew what she looked like.
12:28 PM on 12/08/2012
lmao can u say living off the goverment
12:28 PM on 12/08/2012
I think we all did LOL
11:25 AM on 12/08/2012
I remember someone talking about utility rates 'Necessarily Skyrocketing' Here we are, eat it people!
photo
ggg5gebhardt
I am really a cat!
11:08 AM on 12/08/2012
This is a BS story. If she paid her bills she should have proof she paid them. If she had not paid in years, there is no way they would have allowed it to get this high without turning off service.

Someone is not doing their job or is fibbing big time.
11:39 AM on 12/08/2012
Had a neighbor that their meter was pulled off the house by a fallen tree. Ameren came in and reinstalled the meter. Months go by and the lady doesn't get a bill. Ameren comes out on their own, and find that the meter was not inserted correctly. Electricity was going through, but not registering, Guess what? SHE GOT A BILL going back those months she used and didn't pay.
08:10 AM on 12/08/2012
We had an ice storm here in Kentucky about 4 years ago and I didn't have electricity for 13 days. My utility bill was over $300.00. I was shocked as it normally runs around $150.00/month. The utility company said it was right. All my neighbors were complaining too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zitoameriki2
Obama = Epic Fail
12:11 AM on 12/08/2012
Just an FYI, I spoke with my electric company over my last month's bill and how it was so expensive even though I had 5 days without power from Sandy....and they said it was an accurate reading from my meter.... and I told them I have NEVER seen anyone come to my house for a meter reading. They said they dont need to anymore, its all wireless now, and can read your meter from a truck 1000 feet away.

This is too easy to hack... check your actual meters no matter what they say, glitches can easily occur here.
11:42 PM on 12/07/2012
Lets take a look at the math here first, 15,000 dollars could equate to 2 years late or 2 years of payments that were posted to a wrong account number via the accounts receivable department at Dominion Power. At 625 a month for 2 years you could easily add up the debt to 15,000 dollars owed. An internal audit of the accounting department could have revealed that even though her payments were cleared, that they were applied to a wrong account number which can happen. Even when you pay via online. In that process a check is printed from your bank with all your information on it, and sent to the company on your behalf that you owe. If someone is sick or suffering from allergies which is common here on the East Coast, then they could have simply mistyped the wrong account number via "fat finger". When the check cleared it would still show up as paid giving false sense of successful payment to the person. And yes, some of you non-east people will say how can you have an electric/gas bill that high? Well its quite simple, and that is because there is a monopoly on power out there, and there is little choice who you can go with.
11:22 PM on 12/07/2012
There is WAY TOO MUCH FRAUD by both consumers AND corporations that TOTALLY needs to be investigated. Law enforcement, irresponsible policies and spending as well as failures by regulators are all FAILING the American public, and MORALITY!!!
11:20 PM on 12/07/2012
Who has been HACKING CITY PAYMENT RECORDS????
11:18 PM on 12/07/2012
Most utility companies SHUT OFF the eletricity BEFORE the bill becomes that outrageous...what are they doing, GROWING DOPE????
10:07 PM on 12/07/2012
Huffington Post has left out a lot of details. Here's the local report:
http://wtvr.com/2012/12/05/how-does-richmond-let-a-resident-run-up-a-15000-utilities-bill/

She questioned a bill in 2008 and the city put a hold on her account while they investigated. My take is that they never put it into the computer to release the hold, yet meanwhile she continued to receive the utility (gas and water only - electricity is billed by Va Power) and her bill kept rising for at least four years. In 2012, she moved to the adjoining county. I'm betting that since she didn't want to open up a bag of worms, she never called to cancel her utilities. The next tenant is probably still using her account. Also, the neighbor who said his normal bill is about $100 a month is probably either not telling the truth or has his bill subsidized. 35th St. in the city is a very old section and the homes don't tend to have up to date insulation and windows. I live in the county and heat my newer home and hot water with gas, which is furnished by the same Department of Utilities she's dealing with. Summer bills as far as gas goes are cheap, but winter bills can be several hundred dollars each month.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zitoameriki2
Obama = Epic Fail
12:07 AM on 12/08/2012
Puffington Post always leaves out details.... they always lie or spin the truth. Its what they do.
09:19 PM on 12/07/2012
"Somebody needs to help me." America 2012. Not only can you not help yourself, you don't know how to ask for help???
11:46 PM on 12/07/2012
Bingo! As the last election showed we are now an entitlement society. Everyone deserves everything simply because they happen to have their feet on American soil (legally or not). Why learn to do for yourself when Uncle Sam will do it for you?
05:45 PM on 12/07/2012
I hope for her sake she has a record of her payments she claims to have made! These days it's hard to say, after all you have lotto winners collecting food stamps.
03:52 PM on 12/07/2012
"An error on the city's part meant Bagby was never notified that the city was charging her for payments she said she paid."

That's the key sentence in the entire article, and it makes no sense. How do you get "charged" for "payments"?
04:42 PM on 12/07/2012
It sounds to me like there was an issue where they were billing her but not sending her bills, hence she was never "notified." I would bet anything she was perfectly content to not be getting utility bills, probably for years, and then when they found the error they wanted the money she never paid. And just fyi, in court you can't plead ignorance if you knew you were getting something for free and never checked into the situation.
05:09 PM on 12/07/2012
And I bet you are EXACTLY right. The only side we're seeing here is her side and I have my doubts she's giving up ALL the facts that are pertinent. I bet you her last electric bill that she knew she wasn't getting billed and she knew she wasn't making payments, in truth.
11:17 AM on 12/08/2012
Spot on. If she's writing checks and the utility isn't getting them, she'll know when she checks her balance. If they're going to wrong account, all she has to do is have the bank send copies of the cleared checks showing payments were made and deposited. You nailed it. There was an accounting error that let her have utilities for free, and like a good little thief, she took it and ran, and now she's whining when she got caught.
03:10 PM on 12/07/2012
Never pay such a bill, it's atrocious what these companies try to get away with. AT&T tried to send my husband and me a nearly 4 thousand dollar bill for a 2 month period while he was DEPLOYED, and the phones weren't even in use. We used them a total of 3 times in that period (we had a landline back then, cells were for deployment calls only), and the majority of it was for "roaming." Didn't matter we got the phones exclusively for when he was deployed on a proper plan for such calls. Despite the amount being 2 MONTHS of our pay, they tried for months to threaten us into paying. We left them and when AT&T bought our new phone company later on, they tried to reinstate the debt! At that point we left them again and threatened to go to the media if they ever contacted us again. Someone finally listened, the so-called debt went away.

And yet we need LESS regulation on companies! They've gotta be able to keep breaking those record profit margins, right? They can't do that if we dare to demand proper treatment! Silly consumers, what are we thinking? Let me get my checkbook.
04:19 PM on 12/07/2012
Actually in this case all the regulation in the world clearly doesn't matter. It's PUBLIC utility.
07:37 PM on 12/07/2012
If they're demanding an unreasonable bill from you, does it MATTER if its a public utility or a phone? No. It was just an example anyway.
04:22 PM on 12/07/2012
Oh no you don't. Be outraged at what AT&T did because nobody should be treated that way, but you handled it absolutely correctly. Leave them, inform your friends and relatives, and if necessary, go to the media. However, you need to leave the government out of it. A company that doesn't listen to it's customers will see the profits fall or even go out of business on its own. My tax dollars don't need to be used to keep them alive by regulating their behavior.
07:39 PM on 12/07/2012
So far as I can tell, AT&T is still one of the major providers, hardly going out of business. That's with confirmation they have the worst customer service of telephone/cell companies. When people are threatened and locked into expensive contracts, the "customers will just go elsewhere" argument holds less water.

And yes, your tax dollars do go to regulation of public entities, unless you want to see more victimization of innocent people just for your selfish desire to not be properly taxed. This is not a tax issue anyway, so please stay on topic.